What do you mean? It looks perfect in the scan.
Not sure what he's talking about with Gurgle. My opinion of PSA has changed a lot lately, for the better. For one thing, their customer service is excellent. For another, they have very consistent grading standards for the most part. Once one understands them anyway.
The one thing they do have trouble being consistent on with wackys is how the copyright line affects the centering. If you look on ebay, you'll see many examples of wackys where the copyright line is right up against the bottom of the card receiving grades of 8 or 9. In the mind of the grader, the image needs to be centered and the copyright is not really important (sometimes,anyway).
They are definitely wrong about this. The copyright line should be considered part of the image, and treated accordingly when computing centering. Other than that I have no complaints with PSA anymore. They're human like anyone else, but they do a great job all things considered.